SAP SuccessFactors Alternatives: 6 HCM Platforms Compared

SAP SuccessFactors is an enterprise staple, but its complexity, cost, and legacy architecture drive many organisations to explore alternatives. These 6 platforms offer modern interfaces, faster deployment, and better value.

Watch: Top SAP SuccessFactors Alternatives

Best SAP SuccessFactors Alternatives

Why Companies Leave SAP SuccessFactors

High Total Cost of Ownership

License fees, implementation consultants, and ongoing maintenance make SuccessFactors one of the most expensive HCM platforms. Total costs often exceed $50-100/user/month.

Poor User Experience

The interface is widely criticised as unintuitive. Employee adoption suffers, and HR teams spend excessive time on basic tasks that modern platforms handle easily.

Long Implementations

Full SuccessFactors deployments take 6-18 months with expensive consultants. Modern platforms like Rippling and BambooHR deploy in days or weeks.

Slow Innovation

Product updates are less frequent and less impactful than cloud-native competitors like Workday and Rippling, which ship features weekly.

Best SAP SuccessFactors Alternatives

1. Workday

Best for: Cloud-native enterprise HCM

Rating: 9/10 | Pricing: Custom (typically $20-40/user/month)

Strengths

True cloud architecture (vs SuccessFactors' hybrid)
Better user experience
Unified financial + HR platform
Stronger analytics and reporting
More frequent product updates

Considerations

Similarly expensive
Long implementation (6-18 months)
Complex for smaller organisations
Requires dedicated admin resources

Best For: Large enterprises (2,000+ employees) wanting a modern, cloud-native HCM to replace SuccessFactors' legacy architecture

2. Rippling

Best for: Modern HR + IT + payroll with rapid deployment

Rating: 9.3/10 | Pricing: $8/user/month (base)

Strengths

Dramatically faster implementation
70-80% less expensive
Combines HR, IT, and payroll
Superior automation engine
Modern, intuitive interface

Considerations

Less suited for 5,000+ employees
Fewer enterprise-grade compliance features
Smaller professional services team
Less customisable for complex orgs

Best For: Mid-market companies (100-2,000 employees) wanting enterprise capabilities without SuccessFactors' complexity and cost

3. Oracle HCM Cloud

Best for: Oracle ecosystem integration

Rating: 8.5/10 | Pricing: Custom (typically $15-30/user/month)

Strengths

Best for companies already on Oracle ERP
Strong financial integration
Good global capabilities
Comprehensive talent management
AI-powered recommendations

Considerations

Similarly complex to implement
User experience lags behind Workday
Expensive for standalone use
Best when paired with Oracle stack

Best For: Enterprises (2,000+ employees) already invested in Oracle ERP looking for a tightly integrated HCM

4. BambooHR

Best for: Simple, affordable alternative for SMBs

Rating: 8.7/10 | Pricing: $12-22/user/month

Strengths

95% cheaper than SuccessFactors
Implementation in days, not months
Best-in-class ease of use
Strong employee self-service
No consultant fees required

Considerations

Not suitable for 1,000+ employees
US-focused payroll only
Limited enterprise compliance
Fewer global capabilities

Best For: SMBs (25-500 employees) that have outgrown spreadsheets but don't need enterprise HCM

5. Lattice

Best for: Performance-focused platform for growing companies

Rating: 9.2/10 | Pricing: $11/user/month

Strengths

Best-in-class performance management
Strong OKR and goal alignment
Modern engagement surveys
90% cheaper than SuccessFactors
Faster time-to-value

Considerations

No payroll or core HRIS depth
Not a full HCM replacement
Less suitable for 5,000+ employees
Limited compliance features

Best For: Growing companies (100-2,000 employees) where performance management is the priority, not full HCM

6. Deel

Best for: Global workforce management and EOR

Rating: 9/10 | Pricing: Free HRIS, $49/contractor, $599/EOR employee/month

Strengths

Free HRIS for global teams
Hire in 150+ countries without entities
Faster global expansion than SuccessFactors
Strong contractor and compliance management
No implementation project needed

Considerations

Less mature for large enterprise HRIS needs
EOR model expensive at scale
Fewer talent management features
Less suited for single-country operations

Best For: Global companies (50-2,000 employees) needing to hire internationally faster than SuccessFactors allows

Quick Comparison: SuccessFactors vs Alternatives

Feature	SuccessFactors	Workday	Rippling	BambooHR
Pricing	$20-40/user	$20-40/user	$8/user base	$12-22/user
Implementation	6-18 months	6-18 months	Weeks	Days
UI/UX	Dated	Modern	Modern	Excellent
Global Capability	Excellent	Excellent	Good	Limited
Enterprise Features	Excellent	Excellent	Good	Basic
Best For	5,000+	2,000+	100-2,000	25-500

Switching from SAP SuccessFactors?

Download our Enterprise HR Software Comparison Guide with feature matrices, pricing breakdowns, and migration planning checklists.

View Enterprise HR Comparison